Help me choose a new breeding male?

Hi! I have two males that I've been tossing up over for a wee while and decided it might be best to as all you which you like better and would be more likely to breed with?

Here are the two:

Kilída He has 239 stats currently, Charming personality, and more exclusive marks

Selkie 321 stats at the moment, Imaginative personality - less exclusive marks but also so pretty :0 - will likely change his base to a tier II when events come

So what do you guys think?? 

While I do like both, I feel like the first stands out more. If you want more natural pups then the second is the way to go. But I’d definitely send requests to the first

Definitely the second for me <3 I'm not generally even a fan of merle, but he's so cohesive and naturally pretty 

I would go for the first one simply because of the Tier II base - you just have more options, looks wise.

A possible customization of Kilída - is this any better than the original?

Yeah I definitely like the second version better

I'm a fan of Selkie :o. I would just change his base to something Tier 2!

 Kilída has been chosen as my new breeding male! feel free to check him out ;)